2nd Chance Sunrise
Sea Isle City Restaurant Guide
The Best Restaurants, Breakfast, Seafood & Family Dining in Sea Isle City
One of the best parts of a Sea Isle City vacation is discovering the incredible local food scene. Whether you're looking for fresh seafood, authentic Italian cuisine, a family-friendly restaurant after a day at the beach, or the perfect place for date night, Sea Isle City has something for everyone.
After years of vacationing here and now owning 2nd Chance Sunrise, we've enjoyed just about every restaurant on the island. This guide shares our personal favorites along with local recommendations to help you plan memorable meals during your stay.
⭐ Our Quick Picks
🥩 Best Overall Restaurant (Tie)
A Modo Mio & Basilicos
🍳 Best Breakfast
Steak Out Breakfast & Lunch
Off Island - Marge's Diner
🍩 Best Donuts
Maryanne Pastry Shoppe
🦀 Best Seafood
Mike's Seafood
🍕 Best Pizza
Berradi's
🍦 Best Ice Cream
Marita's Homemade Ice Cream
🍹 Best Outdoor Dining
The Point
🌅 Best Sunset Dinner
Sunset Pier Restaurant
Which Restaurant Fits Your Vacation?
First Night in Town
Berardi Brothers • Azzurra • Anthony's
Date Night
A Modo Mio • Basilicos • Coastal Chop House • Sole
Fresh Seafood
Mike's Seafood • O'Donnell's • Anthony's
Family Dinner
Mike's Seafood • O'Donnell's • Sunset Pier
Outdoor Dining
The Point • Sunset Pier • Deauville (food ok, but great water views)
Casual Lunch
Berardi Brothers • Mrs. Brizzles • Sunset Pier
Breakfast Restaurants
Here's a list of Sea Isle breakfast restaurants:
Rick's Breakfast House
Address: 63rd Street, across from ACME
Contact: 609-263-0030
www.ricksbreakfast.com
Distance: Approximately 12 minute walk
Start your day off right at Rick's Breakfast House, a popular spot for locals and vacationers alike. With friendly service and delicious breakfast options, it's the perfect way to fuel up for a day of fun in Sea Isle City.
Steak-Out Breakfast and Lunch
Address: Landis Avenue, between 40th Street and JFK Boulevard
Contact: 609-263-7000
www.steakoutsea.com
Distance: Approximately 11 minute walk
Experience the charm of traditional American breakfast at Steak-Out Breakfast and Lunch. With a menu that caters to both locals and vacationers, it's the perfect spot to start your day in Sea Isle City.
Details: Open year round, it's where the locals go in the off season, can get crowded, quality breakfast.
Italian Restaurants
Here's a list of Sea Isle Italian restaurants:
A Modo Mio Ristorante
Corner of 59th Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-6600
www.amodomioristorante.com
Distance: Approximately 9 minute walk
Indulge in Old World Italian cuisine at A Modo Mio Ristorante, where casual outdoor dining meets classy indoor ambiance. Don't forget to check out their sister restaurant, La Finestra Ristorante, located on the corner of Pleasure Avenue and JFK Boulevard, offering an upscale Italian menu in a sophisticated setting. Both are BYOB, making for a perfect dining experience.
Details: In our opinion the best and most consistent Italian food and service on the island, even better than La Finestra their sister restaurant. Gets very busy and loud, book reservations in advance. Specials are usually incredible, but be warned they are $50-$60. Try the Gnocchi alle Noci, our favorite.
Andrea Trattoria Italiana II at KIX Complex
Contact: 609-263-5001
www.andreatrattoria.com
Distance: Approximately 15 minute walk
Savor the flavors of Naples at Andrea Trattoria Italiana II, where Owner Andrea Covino brings authentic Italian cuisine to Sea Isle City. Located as a part of the KIXX complex, this family-run restaurant offers a warm atmosphere and delectable dishes, making it the ideal spot for a weekend dinner.
Anthony's Sea Isle City
Distance: Approximately 1.8 miles, easy bike ride or a quick drive (parking limited) or jitney ride.
Experience modern cuisine with an Italian influence at Anthony's Sea Isle City. Owned by vacationer-turned-restaurateur Anthony Foster, this seasonal gem promises familiar eats with a touch of sophistication. With a long standing reputation for delicious cuisine, Anthony's Sea Isle City is pleased to expand to this lovely new location. Featuring a full service bar complete with hand crafted cocktails, with a roomier and more comfortable dining room.
Details: We've been to the new Anthony's location and its very good, the vide on the bar side is lively and fun, servers work very hard, pricing is not bad for the Island. The other side of the dining area looks like a wedding venue, a bit odd for dinner.
Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria
Address: 4300 Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-1010
www.basilicospizza.com
Distance: Approximately 10 minute walk
Since 1999, Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria has been a staple of Sea Isle City, offering a diverse menu that caters to every palate. From homemade pasta to fresh seafood dishes and traditional Italian favorites, there's something for everyone to enjoy.
Details: This is one of our favorites, no frills, small, a true old school family run business.
La Finestra Ristorante
Address: Corner of Pleasure Avenue and JFK Boulevard, Sea Isle City, NJ
Phone: 609-486-5033
Website: https://www.lafinestranj.com/
Distance: Approximately 14 minute walk
Details: The sister restaurant to A Modo Mio, La Finestra offers an upscale Italian menu in a sophisticated setting. It’s a great spot for a fancy night out, though we find A Modo Mio’s consistency edges it out. BYOB to elevate your meal.
La Fontana Coast (Sea Isle City)
Address: 50th Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-7700
www.lafontanacoast.com
Distance: Approximately 3 minute walk
Indulge in traditional Italian cuisine at La Fontana Coast. Owned and operated by Head Chef Bujar Daku and his brother Gani Daku, this restaurant offers a taste of Philadelphia's regional flavors. From homemade pasta to fresh seafood dishes, La Fontana Coast promises an unforgettable dining experience.
Details: Can be crowded and noisy, but always entertaining, outside seating in the summer is our choice. Make sure to make reservations, they offer coupons and specials throughout the year.
Sole Sea Isle City
Address: Landis Avenue, adjacent to 86th Street
Contact: 609-263-5600
www.soleseaic.com
Distance: Approximately 10 minute bike ride or quick car ride, 1.8 miles
Indulge in upscale yet casual dining at Sole Sea Isle City, where Italian Mediterranean cuisine takes center stage. With a well-balanced menu and excellent service, it's the perfect spot for a memorable meal.
Details: Another one of our go to places on the Island. The calamari is amazing, pizza is good, and just about everything else. Another BYOB spot perfect for a date night (depending on season).
Pizza & Casual Favorites
Here's a list of Sea Isle breakfast restaurants:
Azzurra Pizza and Ristorante
Corner of 51st Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-1872
www.azzurraseaislecity.com
Distance: Approximately 2-3 minute walk, 1.5 blocks away
For over 35 years, Azzurra Pizza has been delighting locals and vacationers alike with its mouthwatering pizzas and Italian fare. Open seven days a week for lunch and dinner, this popular spot is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy.
Details: Open year round, consistent, and they deliver to the beach or house, one of our go to places, try the Grandma pizza.
Berardi Brothers Pizza
Address: 4400 Landis Avenue (New Location)
Contact: 609-263-6209
www.berardispizza.com
Distance: Approximately 7 minute walk
With a legacy dating back to the 1970s, Berardi Brothers Pizza is a Sea Isle institution known for its fresh, handmade pies. Made with love by brothers Nick and Mike, each pizza promises a taste of tradition and quality.
Details: Very good quality pizza, mozzarella sticks are the biggest we've ever seen, freeze really well in case you leftovers. Allow extra time when ordering in the summer, it usually takes longer than they say.
Casa Taco Bayfront Taqueria
Address: Corner of Landis Avenue and JFK Boulevard
Contact: 609-263-3474
www.casatacoseaisle.com
Distance: Approximately 12 minute walk
Craving Mexican food? Look no further than Casa Taco Bayfront Taqueria. Located on Park Road, this restaurant offers all your favorite Mexican dishes, from tacos to fajitas, in a casual, BYOB setting.
DeNunzio's Brick Oven Pizza and Grille
Address: The Spinnaker, Boardwalk
Contact: 609-263-2600
www.denunziospizzeria.com
Distance: Approximately 18 minute walk
Craving award-winning pizza? Look no further than DeNunzio's Brick Oven Pizza and Grille. Located on the Boardwalk at The Spinnaker, this family-friendly spot serves up delicious pizzas and other Italian favorites that are sure to please the whole family.
Drifters Feel Good Food
Address: Landis Avenue, between JFK Boulevard and 40th Street
Contact: 609-263-2700
www.driftersfeelgoodfood.com
Distance: Approximately 15 minute walk
For a unique dining experience, head to Drifters Feel Good Food. This eatery offers a diverse menu of mouthwatering dishes, served up in a casual atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a late-night snack or a hearty meal, Drifters has something for everyone.
Details: Walk up greasy spoon serving some of the best late night snacks in the perfect location for those leaving the OD. Owner is very hands on, funnel cake is our go to. Their motto is they don't close until the streets are empty.
Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria
Address: Mediterranean-style dining room, Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-2727
www.fratelliswoodfiredpizzeria.com
Distance: Approximately 3 minute walk
Experience the authentic flavors of Italy at Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria. Featuring a wood-burning oven imported from Italy, this restaurant offers gourmet and personal pizzas, along with a casual menu for lunch and dinner.
Details: One of our go to places, the large margherita pizza is one of our favs. Service is hit or miss and sometimes entertaining, go with a lot of patience. BYOB, uncork before you arrive or else you might be waiting a long time for your wine to be opened.
Hank Sauce Restaurant
Address: 8605 Landis Avenue, between 86th and 85th Streets
Contact: 609-263-2100
www.hanksaucerestaurant.com
Distance: Approximately 10 minute bike ride or quick car ride, 1.8 miles
Discover the flavors of South Jersey at Hank Sauce Restaurant. Located on Landis Avenue, this establishment offers a menu of modern American food, all made with the unique flavors of Hank Sauce. From burgers to seafood, there's something for every palate at Hank Sauce.
Details: Hank's pulled pork is our go to.
LouDogs
Address: 3800 Boardwalk on the Promenade
609-263-DOGS
It began in the summer of ‘82. That’s when Lou Subashi opened up a hot dog cart on 75th Street beach in Sea Isle. Before you could spit out an order for — “a dog with German mustard, ketchup, diced onions & a hint of kraut to taste,” — the LouDog was born. It quickly became more than just a local business, but instead a family, a community, a go to in Sea Isle and beyond. That cart stood until 2010. Because of your dedication & loyalty, we were able to expand our menu & open up an indoor shop located right in the heart of town on 38th & Pleasure.
Oar House Pub
Address: 42nd Place, across from Public Parking lot
Contact: 609-263-3000
www.oarhousepub.com
Distance: Approximately 18 minute walk
Formerly known as the Lobster Loft, the Oar House Pub offers a lively atmosphere and a diverse menu of seafood and American cuisine. With indoor and outdoor bars, it's the perfect spot for lunch, dinner, and nightlife fun.
Ocean Drive Sand Bar and Grill
Address: 40th Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-1000
www.theod.com
Distance: Approximately 15 minute walk
Experience a taste of history at the Ocean Drive Bar and Restaurant, a Sea Isle City landmark since 1885. With live entertainment and delicious food, it's the perfect place to enjoy the vibrant nightlife of the Jersey Shore.
O'Donnell's Pour House
Address: 39th Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-5600
www.odonellspourhouse.com
Distance: Approximately 16 minute walk
Step into the cozy atmosphere of O'Donnell's Pour House, Sea Isle City's only Irish pub. With traditional Irish fare and seafood options, it's a delightful spot for lunch, dinner, and live entertainment.
Phil's Famous Pizzeria
Address: 38th Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-0700
www.philsfamouspizzeria.com
Distance: Approximately 17 minute walk
Satisfy your pizza cravings at Phil's Famous Pizzeria, a Sea Isle City institution since 1977. With their famous "Upside Down" pizza and mouthwatering cheesesteaks, it's the perfect place for a late-night bite.
Details: Barstool Sports Pizza Review in 2022 - 7.6
Steak-Out Breakfast and Lunch
Address: Landis Avenue, between 40th Street and JFK Boulevard
Contact: 609-263-7000
www.steakoutsea.com
Distance: Approximately 11 minute walk
Experience the charm of traditional American breakfast at Steak-Out Breakfast and Lunch. With a menu that caters to both locals and vacationers, it's the perfect spot to start your day in Sea Isle City.
Sunset Pier Restaurant and Juice Bar
Address: 86th Street and the Bay
Contact: 609-263-5200
www.sunsetpier.com
Distance: Approximately 10 minute bike ride or quick car ride, 1.8 miles, parking can be tough to find
Savor delicious food with a view at Sunset Pier Restaurant and Juice Bar. Whether you're enjoying breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the diverse menu and friendly service make it a must-visit destination.
Details: One of our favorites, breakfast, lunch and of course dinner during golden hour, mahi sandwich is one of our favs. Best to bike or jitney here, parking is very tough.
The Point - Sea Isle City
Address: 43rd Street, off the Boardwalk
Contact: 609-263-1000
www.thepointseaislecity.com
Distance: Approximately 10 minute walk
Experience a taste of island paradise at The Point - Sea Isle City. With creative mixed drinks, live entertainment, and a unique food menu, it's the perfect spot to relax and unwind during the summer months.
Details: Fun vibe, can get really crowded depending on the band, food is typical bar fare, kids have to leave after 5pm.
Twisties Tavern on the Bay (Reopened)
Address: Bayview Drive, Strathmere
Contact: 609-263-2200
URL: www.twistiestavern.com
Distance: Approximately 8 minutes drive
Indulge in tavern-style food and breathtaking views at Twisties Tavern on the Bay. Whether you're dining indoors or outdoors, you'll enjoy a taste of nostalgia and a delicious meal.
Details: Hidden gem alert, we don't even want to mention Twisties as it's already tough to get into. We love it during the off season when it's all local's. Good food, old school vibe and just how we like it.
Uncle Oogie's Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches
Address: Adjacent to Rick's Breakfast and ACME
Contact: 609-263-6086
www.uncleoogies.com
Distance: Approximately 12 minute walk
Treat yourself to a variety of pizzas and specialty sandwiches at Uncle Oogie's Pizzeria. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying curbside pickup, you're in for a flavorful experience.
Zio Niccolo Pizza
Address: Boardwalk, between 42nd and 43rd Streets
Contact: 609-263-2977
www.zioniccolopizza.com
Located on the Promenade, Zio Niccolo brings you pizza ,sandwiches, & apps by the beach, pick up or delivery available.
Distance: Approximately 12 minute walk
Seafood & Steak
Coastal Chop House
Address: Corner of 40th Street and Landis Avenue
Contact: 609-263-2000
Facebook page
Distance: Approximately 15 minute walk
Experience the timeless allure of a classic American steakhouse, reimagined with local ingredients and coastal elegance. BYOB
Details: Opened in summer of 2026 in the old Shoobies location.
Carmen's Seafood
Address: 43rd Place
Contact: 609-263-1634
www.carmensseafood.com
Distance: Approximately 18 minute walk
For over four decades, Carmen's Seafood has been serving up some of the freshest seafood dishes in Sea Isle City. Located on 43rd Place, this waterfront restaurant offers stunning bay views and a menu that showcases the best of the sea.
Details: Very underrated breakfast, BYOB, check-in day hang-out with delivery service from KIX. You can also boat here and tie up.
Henri's Bar at Braca Cafe
Address: JFK Boulevard and Pleasure Avenue
Contact: 609-263-4271
www.bracacafe.com
Distance: Approximately 14 minute walk
Step back in time at Henri's Bar at Braca Cafe. With over 110 years of history, this establishment offers a blend of tradition and modern refinement. Featuring classic American cuisine and seafood options, Henri's Bar is the perfect spot for a memorable dining experience.
Details: Henri's outdoor bar is beautiful and has a great vibe. Drink prices are VERY high, service and food quality is hit or miss.
Marie's Lobster House and Fish Market
Address: Located on 43rd Place
Contact: 609-263-3474
www.marieslobsterhouse.com
Distance: Approximately 17 minute walk
For fresh seafood and ocean views, head to Maries Lobster House and Fish Market. This family-owned restaurant has been serving up delicious seafood for over 70 years. Whether you're dining on the outdoor deck or grabbing takeout, Maries Lobster House promises a memorable dining experience.
Details: Marie's looks the same as it always has, and that's part of the appeal. You won't leave hungry and will appreciate walking back after a traditional meal, oh and the bread.....
Mike's Seafood of Sea Isle City
Address: 43rd Place and Park Road
Contact: 609-263-3458
www.mikesseafood.com
Distance: Approximately 17 minute walk
For over a century, Mike's Seafood has been a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving a leisurely dockside meal or fresh seafood to enjoy at home, Mike's Seafood has you covered.
Details: Our go to with large groups of friends and relatives, expect to wait during the summer. It's BYOB and many people roll in with coolers. Once seated each group walks up and orders, makes splitting the bill easy. Fun vibe, good seafood and open air, nothing better. Mike is a sponsor of many Charitable events on the Island including Mike's seafood run/walk for autism
Local Dining Tips
After many family vacations in Sea Isle City, here are a few tips we've learned:
✔ Make dinner reservations early during July and August.
✔ BYOB restaurants fill up quickly on weekends.
✔ Many restaurants open earlier than expected, making early dinners easier with young children.
✔ Parking can be challenging during peak dinner hours—walking is often easier if you're staying nearby.
✔ Don't skip dessert at Marita's Homemade Ice Cream after dinner.
✔ Breakfast spots get busy before 10 AM. Arrive early or enjoy a leisurely brunch after the beach crowd clears.
Walk to Dinner
One of the biggest advantages of staying at 2nd Chance Sunrise is being able to leave your car parked.
Many of Sea Isle City's most popular restaurants, coffee shops, bars, ice cream shops, and the promenade are all within walking distance. After dinner, enjoy a relaxing stroll along the promenade before returning home to unwind by your private heated pool.
Continue Planning Your Sea Isle City Vacation
Explore more local guides:
☕ Coffee & Baked Goods Guide
🍽️ Restaurants Guide
🎵 Bars & Live Music Guide
🎬 Movies Under the Stars
🎶 Concerts Under the Stars
🏀 Community Center Guide
🏖️ Live Beach Cam
👨👩👧👦 Things To Do With Kids
Ready to Experience Sea Isle City?
Whether you're planning family dinners, romantic date nights, or grabbing ice cream after a day at the beach, staying at 2nd Chance Sunrise puts you within walking distance of many of Sea Isle City's favorite restaurants and attractions.
🏊 Private Heated Pool
🏖️ Beach-Block Location
🌊 Ocean Views
👨👩👧👦 Family-Friendly Home